Superman #51
Released: March/April 1948
Story: Alvin Schwartz
Art: Win Mortimer, Curt Swan
Cover: Wayne Boring
- CGC 4.0 – $120
- Ungraded: $100 – $249
The issue pictured above was being offered by Metropolis Comics in 2014 for about $600 dollars. Mr. Mxyztplk appearance in this issue of Superman. Prices for mid-to-low grade copies are fairly affordable.
Superman #52
Released: May/June 1948
Story: Alvin Schwartz, Samachson, Hamilton
Art: Win Mortimer, Ira Yarbrough
Cover: Wayne Boring
- CGC 6.0 – $320 – $355
There is a Prankster appearance in this issue. Few copies have sold on the public market during the past year or so.
Superman #53
Released: July/August 1948
Story: Finger, Schwartz, Cameron
Art: Al Plastino, Wayne Boring, Stan Kaye
Cover: Wayne Boring, Stan Kaye
- CGC 7.0 – $1,715
- CGC 6.5 – $960
- CGC 5.5 – $565 – $690
- CGC 4.0 – $409 – $490
- CGC 3.5 – $455
- CGC 2.5 – $375
- CGC 2.0 Apparent Restoration – $200
- CGC 1.8 – $205
- Ungraded $100 – $420+
The Origin of Superman is retold in this 10th anniversary issue. Considered to have a classic cover. It’s not particularly difficult to locate a nicer issue for sale, possibly because this was a 10th anniversary issue and collectors over the years might have tried to keep this issue in good condition.
Superman #54
Released: September/October 1948
Story: Bill Finger, Joe Samachson
Art: Al Plastino, Wayne Boring
Cover: Wayne Boring, Stan Kaye
- CGC 7.0 – $330 – $415
- Ungraded – $75 – $200+
There is a full page ad for Dale Evans #1 in this issue.
Superman #55
Released: November/December 1948
- CGC 7.0 – $300
- Ungraded $50 – $60+
Prankster Appearance
Superman #56
Published: January/February 1949
Story: Bill Woolfolk, Alvin Schwartz
Art: Wayne Boring, Al Plastino
Cover: Wayne Boring
- CGC 7.0 – $220
- CGC 4.0 – $145
- Ungraded – $50 – $205
Prankster Appearance
Superman #57
Published: March/April 1949
- CGC 5.5 – $295 – $305
- Ungraded – $55 – $140+
Superman #57 has a unique cover where Lois Lane is flying with Superman in her arms. It states that “In this issue: Lois Lane can do everything Superman can do!”
Superman #58
Released: May/June 1949
- CGC 5.0 – $235
- Ungraded – $70 – $170+
This is the 1st appearance of Tiny Trix. On the front cover it states “Introducing Tiny Trix, the little big shot of the underworld.”
Superman #59
Released: July/August 1949
Story: Bill Woolfolk, Alvin Schwartz
Art: Wayne Boring, Al Plastino
Cover: Wayne Boring
- CGC 5.0 – $205
- CGC 3.5 – $125
- Ungraded – $50 – $200+
Mr. Mxyztplk makes an appearance in Superman #59
Superman #60
Released: September/October 1949
- Ungraded – $90 – $175++
Not many CGC graded copies have sold recently, but the value is consistent with other Superman comic books in this era.
More Superman Comic Book Price Guides
Superman Comic Book Values and Prices Issues #1 – 10
Superman Comic Book Values and Prices Issues #11 – 20
Superman Comic Book Values and Prices Issues #21 – 30
Superman Comic Book Values and Prices Issues #31 – 40
Superman Comic Book Values and Prices Issues #41 – 50
Superman Comic Book Values and Prices Issues #61 – 70
Superman Comic Book Values and Prices Issues #71 – 80